pluribus / 2024autopsy

Theme Statistics

How the spectrum split each theme

Six matrices, one row per top-level theme, segmented Far Left → Far Right. The same distribution looks different through different metrics — finding counts, channel reach, on-air minutes, views, likes, comments.

Theme Distribution

Share of each theme's findings, segmented by the political leaning of the source.

  1. Flawed Strategy & Tactical Incompetence
    21.2%
    36.9%
    18.6%
    3.6%
    19.8%
  2. Neglected Coalition & Demographic Collapse
    16.0%
    26.2%
    24.1%
    5.9%
    27.8%
  3. Ineffective Economic & Policy Messaging
    16.4%
    38.2%
    28.9%
    3.2%
    13.2%
  4. Elitist Culture & 'Woke' Alienation
    14.2%
    24.9%
    28.9%
    7.9%
    24.1%
  5. Flawed Candidacy & Leadership Vacuum
    11.1%
    23.8%
    19.3%
    2.5%
    43.4%
  6. Internal Party Dysfunction & Organizational Decay
    26.5%
    35.4%
    22.1%
    5.3%
    10.6%
  7. Hypocrisy & Corrupt Intent Allegations
    10.3%
    2.3%
    4.2%
    1.9%
    81.2%
  8. Flawed Economics & Corporate Servitude
    53.7%
    15.4%
    14.2%
    16.7%
  9. Foreign Policy & Security Failures
    15.9%
    23.4%
    35.2%
    5.5%
    20.0%
  10. Process-Driven Governmental Failure
    15.4%
    29.4%
    16.1%
    1.4%
    37.8%
  11. Flawed Policy Design & Unpopular Agenda
    29.8%
    26.7%
    8.4%
    3.1%
    32.1%
  12. Media Ecosystem Failure
    16.0%
    45.3%
    12.3%
    1.9%
    24.5%
  13. Ceding Ground on Crime & Immigration
    27.9%
    14.7%
    22.1%
    1.5%
    33.8%
  14. Flawed Economic Paradigm & MMT Critique
    100.0%
  15. Flawed Fundraising & Resource Mismanagement
    91.4%
    2.9%
    2.9%
    2.9%
  16. Canadian Progressive Party Failure (Liberal/NDP)
    6.9%
    93.1%
  17. Allegations of Gross Incompetence & Fraud
    100.0%
  18. Structural & Systemic Disadvantages
    7.1%
    71.4%
    21.4%
  19. Flawed Digital & Media Strategy
    62.5%
    25.0%
    12.5%
  20. Voter Registration & Turnout Deficit
    87.5%
    12.5%
  21. Societal Headwinds & Bigotry
    71.4%
    28.6%
  22. Failure to Challenge Capitalism's Core
    83.3%
    16.7%
  23. Voter Suppression & Election Integrity Failures
    100.0%
  24. Left-Wing Voter Self-Sabotage
    25.0%
    75.0%
  25. Ceding Ground on Armed Legitimacy
    100.0%

Themes by Channel Politics

Distribution of channels that produced findings on each theme.

  1. Ineffective Economic & Policy Messaging
    13.8%
    20.7%
    37.9%
    8.6%
    19.0%
  2. Flawed Strategy & Tactical Incompetence
    14.0%
    21.1%
    36.8%
    8.8%
    19.3%
  3. Internal Party Dysfunction & Organizational Decay
    21.2%
    19.2%
    40.4%
    5.8%
    13.5%
  4. Neglected Coalition & Demographic Collapse
    13.5%
    23.1%
    34.6%
    7.7%
    21.2%
  5. Flawed Candidacy & Leadership Vacuum
    13.7%
    21.6%
    31.4%
    5.9%
    27.5%
  6. Elitist Culture & 'Woke' Alienation
    10.6%
    21.3%
    38.3%
    8.5%
    21.3%
  7. Flawed Policy Design & Unpopular Agenda
    19.4%
    16.1%
    29.0%
    9.7%
    25.8%
  8. Process-Driven Governmental Failure
    23.3%
    20.0%
    23.3%
    3.3%
    30.0%
  9. Ceding Ground on Crime & Immigration
    17.2%
    13.8%
    41.4%
    3.4%
    24.1%
  10. Foreign Policy & Security Failures
    14.8%
    18.5%
    25.9%
    3.7%
    37.0%
  11. Flawed Economics & Corporate Servitude
    24.0%
    16.0%
    44.0%
    16.0%
  12. Media Ecosystem Failure
    20.8%
    25.0%
    20.8%
    4.2%
    29.2%
  13. Hypocrisy & Corrupt Intent Allegations
    19.0%
    14.3%
    23.8%
    9.5%
    33.3%
  14. Flawed Fundraising & Resource Mismanagement
    42.9%
    14.3%
    28.6%
    14.3%
  15. Failure to Challenge Capitalism's Core
    80.0%
    20.0%
  16. Flawed Digital & Media Strategy
    20.0%
    60.0%
    20.0%
  17. Structural & Systemic Disadvantages
    20.0%
    60.0%
    20.0%
  18. Societal Headwinds & Bigotry
    50.0%
    50.0%
  19. Left-Wing Voter Self-Sabotage
    33.3%
    66.7%
  20. Canadian Progressive Party Failure (Liberal/NDP)
    50.0%
    50.0%
  21. Voter Registration & Turnout Deficit
    50.0%
    50.0%
  22. Allegations of Gross Incompetence & Fraud
    100.0%
  23. Ceding Ground on Armed Legitimacy
    100.0%
  24. Flawed Economic Paradigm & MMT Critique
    100.0%
  25. Voter Suppression & Election Integrity Failures
    100.0%

Themes by Views

Where the audience for each theme actually came from.

  1. Process-Driven Governmental Failure
    10.5%
    7.7%
    81.3%
  2. Flawed Strategy & Tactical Incompetence
    3.0%
    55.2%
    8.5%
    32.6%
  3. Hypocrisy & Corrupt Intent Allegations
    16.8%
    82.6%
  4. Ineffective Economic & Policy Messaging
    1.7%
    60.9%
    22.3%
    14.5%
  5. Allegations of Gross Incompetence & Fraud
    100.0%
  6. Internal Party Dysfunction & Organizational Decay
    2.2%
    56.7%
    29.5%
    11.4%
  7. Flawed Candidacy & Leadership Vacuum
    2.4%
    26.6%
    25.7%
    45.1%
  8. Flawed Economics & Corporate Servitude
    2.3%
    13.5%
    32.3%
    51.9%
  9. Neglected Coalition & Demographic Collapse
    3.6%
    29.1%
    6.4%
    1.0%
    59.9%
  10. Elitist Culture & 'Woke' Alienation
    1.9%
    37.7%
    8.1%
    3.3%
    48.9%
  11. Media Ecosystem Failure
    1.6%
    71.3%
    26.1%
  12. Foreign Policy & Security Failures
    22.1%
    2.0%
    75.2%
  13. Flawed Policy Design & Unpopular Agenda
    1.2%
    48.6%
    1.5%
    48.1%
  14. Ceding Ground on Crime & Immigration
    12.2%
    9.4%
    11.8%
    66.6%
  15. Societal Headwinds & Bigotry
    84.0%
    16.0%
  16. Voter Suppression & Election Integrity Failures
    100.0%
  17. Failure to Challenge Capitalism's Core
    51.5%
    48.5%
  18. Canadian Progressive Party Failure (Liberal/NDP)
    2.4%
    97.6%
  19. Flawed Fundraising & Resource Mismanagement
    5.2%
    18.1%
    76.6%
  20. Flawed Digital & Media Strategy
    19.1%
    80.5%
  21. Flawed Economic Paradigm & MMT Critique
    100.0%
  22. Ceding Ground on Armed Legitimacy
    100.0%
  23. Left-Wing Voter Self-Sabotage
    2.1%
    97.9%
  24. Structural & Systemic Disadvantages
    30.2%
    37.2%
    32.6%
  25. Voter Registration & Turnout Deficit
    99.8%

Themes by Airtime

Estimated on-air seconds spent on each theme, partitioned by quadrant.

  1. Flawed Strategy & Tactical Incompetence
    24.1%
    34.5%
    22.7%
    1.8%
    16.8%
  2. Neglected Coalition & Demographic Collapse
    18.0%
    24.2%
    30.5%
    3.6%
    23.7%
  3. Ineffective Economic & Policy Messaging
    17.8%
    30.6%
    36.1%
    3.7%
    11.7%
  4. Elitist Culture & 'Woke' Alienation
    18.6%
    24.8%
    28.3%
    5.1%
    23.3%
  5. Flawed Candidacy & Leadership Vacuum
    11.3%
    22.4%
    23.9%
    5.0%
    37.4%
  6. Internal Party Dysfunction & Organizational Decay
    25.9%
    39.0%
    23.6%
    4.1%
    7.4%
  7. Hypocrisy & Corrupt Intent Allegations
    12.4%
    4.2%
    9.7%
    2.2%
    71.5%
  8. Flawed Economics & Corporate Servitude
    60.8%
    13.0%
    10.9%
    15.4%
  9. Foreign Policy & Security Failures
    15.7%
    31.9%
    34.3%
    3.5%
    14.5%
  10. Process-Driven Governmental Failure
    17.2%
    32.2%
    14.7%
    1.2%
    34.6%
  11. Flawed Policy Design & Unpopular Agenda
    35.6%
    22.9%
    14.8%
    1.4%
    25.3%
  12. Media Ecosystem Failure
    20.1%
    41.7%
    16.2%
    1.9%
    20.1%
  13. Flawed Economic Paradigm & MMT Critique
    100.0%
  14. Ceding Ground on Crime & Immigration
    26.4%
    14.2%
    28.5%
    1.4%
    29.6%
  15. Flawed Fundraising & Resource Mismanagement
    96.3%
    1.6%
    2.1%
  16. Canadian Progressive Party Failure (Liberal/NDP)
    6.9%
    93.1%
  17. Allegations of Gross Incompetence & Fraud
    100.0%
  18. Structural & Systemic Disadvantages
    5.8%
    77.7%
    16.5%
  19. Voter Suppression & Election Integrity Failures
    100.0%
  20. Voter Registration & Turnout Deficit
    73.5%
    26.5%
  21. Societal Headwinds & Bigotry
    65.3%
    34.7%
  22. Failure to Challenge Capitalism's Core
    95.5%
    4.5%
  23. Flawed Digital & Media Strategy
    55.7%
    44.3%
  24. Left-Wing Voter Self-Sabotage
    14.9%
    85.1%
  25. Ceding Ground on Armed Legitimacy
    100.0%

Themes by Likes

Where the engagement came from — likes are a coarser signal of agreement.

  1. Hypocrisy & Corrupt Intent Allegations
    16.7%
    82.5%
  2. Ineffective Economic & Policy Messaging
    1.5%
    62.2%
    25.7%
    1.1%
    9.5%
  3. Flawed Strategy & Tactical Incompetence
    2.4%
    55.7%
    13.6%
    1.5%
    26.9%
  4. Process-Driven Governmental Failure
    12.8%
    8.7%
    77.7%
  5. Internal Party Dysfunction & Organizational Decay
    2.1%
    58.8%
    28.5%
    10.0%
  6. Flawed Candidacy & Leadership Vacuum
    1.9%
    22.3%
    23.9%
    51.5%
  7. Allegations of Gross Incompetence & Fraud
    100.0%
  8. Elitist Culture & 'Woke' Alienation
    1.6%
    32.2%
    8.7%
    5.5%
    52.0%
  9. Neglected Coalition & Demographic Collapse
    2.3%
    20.8%
    13.6%
    1.8%
    61.4%
  10. Flawed Economics & Corporate Servitude
    3.2%
    19.7%
    28.7%
    48.4%
  11. Media Ecosystem Failure
    1.7%
    67.6%
    30.2%
  12. Foreign Policy & Security Failures
    1.2%
    24.5%
    1.5%
    72.7%
  13. Flawed Policy Design & Unpopular Agenda
    2.2%
    62.5%
    1.5%
    1.9%
    32.0%
  14. Ceding Ground on Crime & Immigration
    15.4%
    10.5%
    18.3%
    55.8%
  15. Voter Suppression & Election Integrity Failures
    100.0%
  16. Societal Headwinds & Bigotry
    61.4%
    38.6%
  17. Failure to Challenge Capitalism's Core
    61.0%
    39.0%
  18. Canadian Progressive Party Failure (Liberal/NDP)
    1.5%
    98.5%
  19. Flawed Economic Paradigm & MMT Critique
    100.0%
  20. Flawed Fundraising & Resource Mismanagement
    10.0%
    9.7%
    80.2%
  21. Flawed Digital & Media Strategy
    11.1%
    88.3%
  22. Ceding Ground on Armed Legitimacy
    100.0%
  23. Left-Wing Voter Self-Sabotage
    99.2%
  24. Structural & Systemic Disadvantages
    67.2%
    12.4%
    20.3%
  25. Voter Registration & Turnout Deficit
    97.6%
    2.4%

Themes by Comments

Comments are a coarse signal of intensity, regardless of valence.

  1. Flawed Strategy & Tactical Incompetence
    5.2%
    64.0%
    9.4%
    20.5%
  2. Ineffective Economic & Policy Messaging
    3.1%
    72.1%
    18.8%
    5.1%
  3. Flawed Candidacy & Leadership Vacuum
    4.1%
    49.9%
    17.5%
    28.4%
  4. Process-Driven Governmental Failure
    2.9%
    14.7%
    7.0%
    75.4%
  5. Internal Party Dysfunction & Organizational Decay
    7.5%
    67.2%
    21.6%
    3.3%
  6. Neglected Coalition & Demographic Collapse
    3.5%
    58.6%
    11.4%
    1.1%
    25.5%
  7. Allegations of Gross Incompetence & Fraud
    100.0%
  8. Elitist Culture & 'Woke' Alienation
    3.7%
    69.3%
    12.9%
    4.7%
    9.5%
  9. Hypocrisy & Corrupt Intent Allegations
    2.4%
    19.6%
    77.2%
  10. Media Ecosystem Failure
    3.0%
    93.8%
    2.8%
  11. Flawed Economics & Corporate Servitude
    7.9%
    35.0%
    11.9%
    45.2%
  12. Foreign Policy & Security Failures
    56.9%
    2.0%
    40.1%
  13. Flawed Policy Design & Unpopular Agenda
    2.9%
    71.2%
    1.8%
    23.1%
  14. Ceding Ground on Crime & Immigration
    36.8%
    20.1%
    19.2%
    23.9%
  15. Voter Suppression & Election Integrity Failures
    100.0%
  16. Societal Headwinds & Bigotry
    85.5%
    14.5%
  17. Failure to Challenge Capitalism's Core
    61.9%
    38.1%
  18. Flawed Economic Paradigm & MMT Critique
    100.0%
  19. Canadian Progressive Party Failure (Liberal/NDP)
    4.5%
    95.5%
  20. Flawed Fundraising & Resource Mismanagement
    12.0%
    88.0%
  21. Flawed Digital & Media Strategy
    1.1%
    98.9%
  22. Ceding Ground on Armed Legitimacy
    100.0%
  23. Left-Wing Voter Self-Sabotage
    100.0%
  24. Structural & Systemic Disadvantages
    34.5%
    1.1%
    64.4%
  25. Voter Registration & Turnout Deficit